Although it is welcomed, sanctioning Ben-Gvir and Smotrich is theatre. There are numerous concrete actions Australia could have taken and can still adopt, such as making it illegal for Australian citizens to join the IDF, yet it has not taken such steps.


While Ben-Gvir and Smotrich are undoubtedly violent extremists, they are products of a broader settler-colonial system that is fully backed by the Israeli state. Sanctioning two individuals allows the UK, Australia and its allies to posture as morally upright while continuing arms sales, intelligence sharing, and diplomatic protection for the very military machinery enforcing apartheid and occupation. This isolates the symptom, not the disease.

The ministers are sanctioned for their “incitement”, but not for the actual policies of mass killing, siege, and annexation that are ongoing in Gaza and the West Bank with full cabinet and military approval. So while thousands are being starved, displaced, and bombed, Western governments are still supplying the bombs and pretending that personal sanctions = justice.


This move helps Western governments deflect growing domestic criticism about their own complicity in genocide. It lets them claim they’re “taking action” without changing a single material policy. No arms ban. No prosecution of war crimes. Just a press release and virtue signalling to pacify their own angry publics.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *